College Baseball, MLB Draft, Prospects – Baseball America
Image credit: COLUMBIA, SOUTH CAROLINA – MARCH 23: Tyler Causey #12 of the South Carolina Gamecocks celebrates his home run with his team against the Vanderbilt Commodores in the sixth inning during the second game of their double header at Founders Park on March 23, 2024 in Columbia, South Carolina. (Photo by Eakin Howard/Getty Images)
Well beyond the diamond or any athletic field, a potential sea change in college sports is building. According to several reports this week, the NCAA and some major conferences are deep in negotiations to settle the landmark House v. NCAA antitrust lawsuit and a few related cases.
The House lawsuit, brought by Arizona State swimmer Grant House, seeks damages dating to 2016 for athletes who were not able to earn compensation from their Name, Image and Likeness and also seeks revenue from the NCAA and conferences’ media rights deals. The settlement, according to media reports, would total more than $2.7 billion and be paid out to thousands of athletes.
The money is massive. What’s even more impactful moving forward would be a significant change in how the NCAA operates. The settlement reportedly would come with a commitment from the NCAA and conferences to in the future share revenue from media rights deals with the athletes.
Further, according to a report from Yahoo Sports, the settlement would include a plan to implement roster limits for all sports and the expansion of scholarships to those limits. So, in baseball, there would no longer be a limit of 11.7 scholarships per team. Every team would have as many scholarships as there are roster positions. Today, baseball teams are allowed to have 32 players receiving scholarship money and 40 players total on the roster. A roster size of 32 feels more likely in this potential new reality, but it would undoubtably be subject to major debate before it was set. The new rules would not go into effect for more than a year, according to the report.
For baseball, the change in scholarship limits would be massively impactful. Since 1991, when the NCAA cut scholarships for every sport across the board, baseball has operated with 11.7 scholarships. Increasing the number of scholarships has long been the sport’s white whale. Now, it appears within reach.
While the House lawsuit is about revenue sharing, the writing has been on the wall for scholarship limits since the Supreme Court’s 2021 decision in Alston v. NCAA. Justice Brett Kavanaugh wrote a concurring opinion in that case, in which he attacked the existing NCAA model. Among the flaws he outlined was the equivalency sport model—the NCAA’s term for partial-scholarship sports—and he strongly suggested it would not stand up to a challenge in court, using similar arguments that led to the Alston decision. Kavanaugh’s opinion was not the court’s official decision but given that the justices rendered a unanimous decision in the Alston case, defending the equivalency sports model seemed like a losing proposition for the NCAA.
The settlement of the House lawsuit still has several hurdles to clear, and nothing is close to being finalized. But if the case does get settled, which is the expectation, and that settlement includes the plan to end equivalency sports, college baseball will be forever changed.
Schools would not be required to offer whatever the new scholarship limit would be, just as some schools today do not offer the full 11.7 scholarships for baseball. But the major powers would have potentially nearly tripled the number of scholarships they could offer. That would likely lead to a further concentration of power in the sport and make competition in those leagues even fiercer. That would probably lead to a push to separate baseball into subdivisions, like football. The downstream effects would be massive.
But it would also mean that hundreds, if not thousands, of college baseball players would receive full scholarships instead of graduating with a mountain of student loan debt. It would also be significant for the growth of the sport. Today, baseball is at a disadvantage with multi-sport athletes, who must choose between a full scholarship in basketball or football or a partial scholarship in baseball.
Nothing is finalized yet, but college baseball could be in for the biggest upheaval it has ever experienced.
According to multiple reports, and first reported by Jeff Passan, the San Diego Padres are acquiring second baseman Luis Arraez from the Marlins in return…
This installment collects all transactions involving players who aren’t on 40-man rosters for the period April 22 to May 1. As always, transactions are conveyed…
Charlie Condon’s season has already been remarkable and record setting, and there’s still at least another month to play. Condon last weekend broke both the…
Guardians outfielder Jaison Chourio joins older brother Jackson Chourio on the May update of the Top 100 Prospects. Jackson is the Brewers’ everyday center fielder…
With the complex league season kicking off this weekend, here are 10 intriguing names primed for potential breakouts.
Teddy Cahill and Peter Flaherty break down all the college baseball action from around the country before week 12 of the season. They start with…
The Milwaukee Brewers called up Tyler Black, their No. 4 prospect and the No. 73 MLB prospect, on Tuesday and he went 2-for-4 in his…
The Rockies have promoted former first-round draft pick Jordan Beck who will join the Colorado outfield after posting a .999 OPS in the minor leagues…
Scott Braun, JJ Cooper, Geoff Pontes and Ben Badler discuss the latest Prospect Profile spotlighting Colorado Rockies No. 4 prospect Jordan Beck’s promotion. Iowa Hawkeyes…
This week on the Baseball America Fantasy Podcast, hosts Geoff Pontes and Dylan White cover some of the news of the last week to open…
Everyone is talking velocity and the injury epidemic, but on this week’s episode we ask, “What’s the alternative?” To discuss this far-reaching topic, we invited…
Read the newest magazine issue right on your phone
Join our social media community
211K
219K
324K
21K
13k
Categories
Competition Levels
Subscribe
About
Follow us on:
