To comply with Trump’s orders to end DEI, colleges began removing programs. Including scholarships, in admissions and graduation ceremonies.
Bob Benzel had quite a few people on his mind in 2019.
Bob Benzel and Gerry Sullivan created a fund for five scholarships at Metropolitan Community College in 2019 with the hope of supporting students in specific communities. Now, they’re redirecting it to a foundation based in California, where they live, because of MCC’s new scholarship guidelines.
The students who the former Ralston High School art teacher watched drop out after becoming pregnant.
His mother, who, in her late 30s, earned her GED and associate’s degree while raising four kids by herself.
And Benzel himself, having grown up gay on a farm outside the village of Potter.
Those people led Benzel and his husband, Gerry Sullivan, to create a fund for five scholarships at Metropolitan Community College — money they earmarked to go to single mothers, first-generation students and LGBTQ learners.
That’s who quietly benefited over the past five years. And that’s who Benzel believes will be harmed by MCC’s recent decision to eliminate scholarships with any kind of preference based on a student’s background.
Since March, MCC and other Nebraska colleges and universities have revised their guidelines for awarding scholarships in an attempt, they say, to comply with new guidance from the Trump administration. The directive instructed schools and higher-ed institutions to eliminate long-accepted practices now deemed discriminatory or risk losing federal funding.
MCC’s explanation didn’t fly with Benzel after the foundation director at the time told him they could no longer offer scholarships like the one for LGBTQ students.
Given the option to open the scholarships to all students, Benzel and Sullivan instead took their money back. They plan to donate the remaining $45,000 to a fund supporting LGBTQ students in California, where they now live.
“When do these kids get a chance to get their life together and escape poverty? … If a place like Metropolitan Community College is not actively looking out for these kids, who is?”
Metropolitan Community College officials eliminated scholarship requirements giving preference to specific student groups in the wake of a U.S. Department of Education letter threatening to pull federal funding if colleges didn’t end practices deemed discriminatory. Losing federal funding would be devastating for MCC and the region, an official said.
MCC’s decision to eliminate all preferential scholarships came after Valentine’s Day, when the U.S. Department of Education sent out a “Dear Colleague” letter condemning “pervasive and repugnant race-based preferences and other forms of racial discrimination.”
The letter threatened to pull federal funding from any schools or colleges that failed to end policies and actions deemed discriminatory.
MCC officials did not want to jeopardize federal funding or grants, which benefit a much larger number of students, said Chris Swanson, MCC’s associate vice president of pathway support systems.
“It just made sense to make these changes to protect the greater good and to serve more students as a whole,” Swanson said.
The decision impacted a minuscule number of scholarships and students, Swanson said. Through its foundation, the college offered fewer than 10 preferential scholarships. Most offered smaller dollar amounts that only partially funded a student’s education, and a few were out of funding.
MCC overall offers 200 scholarship types totaling $7 million, some $3.8 million of which comes from taxpayers. Roughly half of the college’s student body receives scholarships, Swanson said.
“On balance,” Swanson said, “we were talking about those small handfuls of things versus Title IV funding for all of our students receiving federal financial aid.”
Those students who previously received scholarships still received funding — it just came from a different source, Swanson said.
Multiple four-year institutions across the state have similarly adjusted their guidelines, including the University of Nebraska system, Chadron State College and Peru State.
The University of Nebraska at Omaha, in particular, is currently facing backlash from multiple entities, including the Equal Protection Project, a campaign led by a nonprofit that opposes race-based policies.
The group filed a complaint with the Department of Education last month alleging two of the university’s scholarships violate Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, which prohibits intentional discrimination on the basis of race, color and/or national origin.
“Regardless of UNO’s reasons for offering, promoting, and administering such discriminatory scholarships, UNO is violating Title VI by doing so,” the complaint states.
On June 25, the Flatwater Free Press found that the university had removed preferential language from two scholarships.
UNO’s Dreamers Pathway scholarship was for Deferred Action of Childhood Arrivals (DACA) or DACA-eligible Nebraska residents. The scholarship is no longer listed on UNO’s scholarship website and the link now leads to the Forward Together scholarship for Nebraska residents.
Its HDR scholarship had a preference for underrepresented minority students at the time the complaint was filed, but UNO has since eliminated that preference from the scholarship’s language.
UNO is one of about 100 institutions across the country that have faced complaints from the group.
In an initial statement, university officials said they continually evaluate the university’s scholarships and are committed to complying with all federal and state laws.
They did not immediately respond to a request for additional comment after Flatwater discovered the changes made to the two scholarships.
Dorothy Endacott, the vice president of marketing communications for the University of Nebraska Foundation, said 65, or 1%, of the foundation’s 5,697 different funds for scholarships are in the process of being modified to be as close as possible to the original intent while complying with the law.
The recent moves come in the wake of a 2023 U.S. Supreme Court ruling outlawing the use of race as a factor in a college’s admissions process.
Paul Weitzel, an assistant professor of law at the University of Nebraska-Lincoln, said the Department of Education’s current interpretation of federal statutes is unprecedented.
“It’s not really clear what’s permissible or impermissible discrimination anymore,” Weitzel said. “It’s an active debate in the country right now whether you should be able to discriminate on the basis of race in a way that helps minorities.”
The debates at MCC are happening across the country, said Wil Del Pilar, the senior vice president of EdTrust, a left-leaning organization that researches and advocates for racial and economic equity in education.
Most institutions are conceding to the new administration, often more than they necessarily need to, for fear of paying for issues to go through the courts, Pilar said. Many had the same reaction to the Supreme Court’s ruling on affirmative action, he added.
A national advocacy group that opposes affirmative action and other race-based policies recently lodged a complaint against the University of Nebraska at Omaha, arguing two of its preferential scholarships are discriminatory. The university said in a statement that it is committed to complying with all federal and state laws.
“There is incredible political pressure that may even be greater than the legal ramifications that institutions may face,” Pilar said, referring to college and university leadership.
Swanson said the stakes at MCC go well beyond any single group of students. If MCC lost federal funding, it would be forced to close.
“The economic engine of our four-county area would crawl to (a) halt,” Swanson said. “And so I think, yes, tens of millions (of dollars) for us, but potentially hundreds of millions for our workforce area.”
While acknowledging the reasons behind MCC’s decision, Benzel said that the students his scholarships supported still need it.
He and Sullivan have since shifted their donations toward the National Rainbow College Fund, administered by a foundation in San Diego.
Benzel predicts the decisions made by MCC and others will have lasting negative impacts.
“I think it’s going to ultimately get other people to be looking at exit ramps out of Nebraska, just like we did,” he said.
Get local news delivered to your inbox!
To comply with Trump’s orders to end DEI, colleges began removing programs. Including scholarships, in admissions and graduation ceremonies.
Metropolitan Community College officials eliminated scholarship requirements giving preference to specific student groups in the wake of a U.S. Department of Education letter threatening to pull federal funding if colleges didn’t end practices deemed discriminatory. Losing federal funding would be devastating for MCC and the region, an official said.
Bob Benzel and Gerry Sullivan created a fund for five scholarships at Metropolitan Community College in 2019 with the hope of supporting students in specific communities. Now, they’re redirecting it to a foundation based in California, where they live, because of MCC’s new scholarship guidelines.
A national advocacy group that opposes affirmative action and other race-based policies recently lodged a complaint against the University of Nebraska at Omaha, arguing two of its preferential scholarships are discriminatory. The university said in a statement that it is committed to complying with all federal and state laws.
Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.
Sorry, an error occurred.
Already Subscribed!
Cancel anytime
Account processing issue – the email address may already exist
Thank you .
Your account has been registered, and you are now logged in.
Check your email for details.
Invalid password or account does not exist
Submitting this form below will send a message to your email with a link to change your password.
An email message containing instructions on how to reset your password has been sent to the email address listed on your account.
No promotional rates found.
Secure & Encrypted
Secure transaction. Secure transaction. Cancel anytime.
Thank you.
Your gift purchase was successful! Your purchase was successful, and you are now logged in.
A receipt was sent to your email.