Halifax
By Jim Bronskill, The Canadian Press
Posted Jun 27, 2025 12:47:46 PM.
Last Updated Jun 27, 2025 04:45:38 PM.
OTTAWA — The Supreme Court of Canada says a woman from Albania should have another chance to argue her immigration case after being denied an appeal due to an expired visa.
In March 2018, Dorinela Pepa came to Canada on a permanent resident visa as a dependent child of her father.
She married shortly before arriving in Canada, which was a surprise to her father. Due to the change in Pepa’s circumstances, her case went through further review.
An admissibility hearing before the Immigration Division of the Immigration and Refugee Board began in September 2018, nine days after Pepa’s visa had expired.
On Oct. 18, 2018, the board issued a removal order barring Pepa from entering Canada for five years. Her father, stepmother and stepbrother now live here.
The Immigration Appeal Division of the board found Pepa had no right to appeal because her visa had already expired when the removal order was issued.
Pepa’s appeals to the Federal Court and the Federal Court of Appeal were unsuccessful, prompting her to turn to the Supreme Court.
In its ruling Friday, the top court said the matter should be sent back to the Immigration Appeal Division for determination of Pepa’s appeal.
Writing for a majority of the court, Justice Sheilah Martin said it was unreasonable for the appeal division to find it lacked jurisdiction to hear the matter under the provision of federal immigration law defining the right of appeal.
The appeal division’s reasons “lack internal rationality” and demonstrate a failure of justification, based on the relevant precedents, the applicable principles of statutory interpretation and the potential effect of the decision on Pepa, Martin wrote.
The appeal division’s reading of the relevant provision of federal immigration law is at odds with Parliament’s object and purpose in enacting the statutory appeal right, Martin said.
The “sole reasonable interpretation” of the immigration law is that the time of arrival in Canada is the point at which a person must hold a visa in order to access the right of appeal against a removal order, Martin added.
The Supreme Court found Pepa had a right to appeal her removal order to the Immigration Appeal Division because she held a permanent resident visa when she entered Canada.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published June 27, 2025.
Jim Bronskill, The Canadian Press
A Nova Scotia RCMP officer is facing yet another sexual assault charge. According to the provincial police watchdog, it laid that charge against Cst. William McNutt, after an allegation was made against…
1h ago
The Nova Scotia government is embarking on a plan to change the way policing is done across the province by ensuring forces meet a standard and by integrating more police into communities. The plan…
1h ago
Environment Canada has issued heat warnings for many areas outside the Halifax Regional Municipality as hot and humid conditions grip much of the province. The agency says regions along the Bay of Fundy…
3h ago
The cause of a house fire in Lower Sackville remains under investigation Wednesday morning. Halifax Regional Fire and Emergency crews were called to a residence on Smokey Drive at 11:40 p.m. following…
3h ago
A Nova Scotia RCMP officer is facing yet another sexual assault charge. According to the provincial police watchdog, it laid that charge against Cst. William McNutt, after an allegation was made against…
1h ago
The Nova Scotia government is embarking on a plan to change the way policing is done across the province by ensuring forces meet a standard and by integrating more police into communities. The plan…
1h ago
Environment Canada has issued heat warnings for many areas outside the Halifax Regional Municipality as hot and humid conditions grip much of the province. The agency says regions along the Bay of Fundy…
3h ago
The cause of a house fire in Lower Sackville remains under investigation Wednesday morning. Halifax Regional Fire and Emergency crews were called to a residence on Smokey Drive at 11:40 p.m. following…
3h ago
The Blue Jays won their Canada Day game to the Yankees, The Raptors lock down Poeltl and Marner is officially out as a Leaf. CityNews’ Sports Reporter Lindsay Dunn has the story.
17h ago
The Carney government has stopped the Digital Services Tax from coming into effect after U.S. President Donald Trump halted ongoing trade talks over the matter. Nick Westoll takes a closer look at the issue.
19h ago
Idaho authorities are investigating a deadly ambush that claimed the lives of two firefighters. Marybel Gonzalez looks at what we know about the person who allegedly started the fire and planned the attack.
19h ago
The Canadian and U.S. governments have resumed trade talks after a digital services tax was pulled off the table. Political correspondent Glen McGregor discusses whether Prime Minister Mark Carney caved in to pressure from U.S President Donald Trump.
Canada quickly rescinded its digital services tax after heated discussions with the U.S. forced trade talks to a standstill.
Now New and Improved! Listen live to NewsRadio Halifax anytime and get breaking-news, traffic, and weather from CityNews Halifax – available for both Android and iOS.